Thanks JLB for following through and making a donation – much appreciated and thanks for your promotion of the site.
There’s many ways to look at Tycho Brahe. Some of the outrageous stories may be made up to make him look ridiculous, in order to distract from his theories.
That said, none of that really matters if Simon’s model works to explain the light movement in the sky. He says it does, and Hoi agrees. Let’s see what those that enjoy studying astronomy have to say.